The Asian As Superior Myth Essay - 603 Words

The author, Ronald Takaki, wishes to illustrate that the perceptions of Asian Americans as a quot;model minorityquot; are not entirely accurate. Takaki writes that the facts and figures used to compare Asian-Americans to other, less successful minority groups are misleading. For example, the author writes that although Japanese Americans are seen as upwardly mobile, they have not yet achieved equality. The essay states that quot;while Japanese American men in California earned an average income comparable to Caucasian men in 1980, they did so only by acquiring more education and working more hours.quot; In addition, the author found that while some Asian American groups do have higher family incomes than Caucasians, at the same time†¦show more content†¦nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;The author does address counter arguments in his paper. He evidently has researched the nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Lozano, p.2 topic quite extensively and has the facts and figures to back up his points. For example, the author states that although there are many successful Asian Americans in the business world, many have hit the quot;glass ceilingquot; and will not rise to the higher ranks of their business. This presents problems for the community and proves that calling Asian Americans the quot;model minorityquot; is not entirely accurate. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;The essay is well-written and very convincing. The author writes it from experience and from his personal observations, both as the grandson of agricultural workers and as a scholar. The essay is useful in understanding that while the public regards Asian Americans as successful, Asians Americans are in most ways just like other minority groups: undereducated, poverty- stricken and unemployed. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;The author may have wanted to lengthen the essay by adding more facts and figures, as well as more interviews with Asian Americans whoShow MoreRelatedChinese Culture And Hyper Sensitivity For Chinese American After 1960s1442 Words   |  6 Pagesexamine importance of the interaction of Chinese culture and hyper-selectivity in constructing a new identity for Chinese American after 1960s. Second, argued that why Chinese American being the â€Å"model minority† is a myth. And lastly, discuss the intention behind the model minority myth and the negative effects of â€Å"over achieving† for Chinese Americans. First of all, cultural factors included the pre-existed Keju system in the Ming dynasty, the college entrance examinations, and after school tutoringRead MoreThe Myth of the Melting Pot1454 Words   |  6 Pagesï » ¿Allison Bergonia English 100 20 September 2013 Myths of the Melting Pot Modern America is considered to be a melting pot, in which a variety of races, cultures, or individuals gather into a unified whole. The ideas of being a new American for people who have migrated from their homeland to America are to leave behind all their past cultures and practices and embrace their new American ways. Is that what really happens? If it was, would there be still racism in America? The number of peopleRead MoreJapanese American Style Essay1576 Words   |  7 Pagesis clearly a yes. The topic that I’m choosing to talk about in relation to this class is the â€Å"Asian Advantage† or the less well-known name, Model minority. From the very beginning of life, Asian Americans are characterized and limited to a specific subset of life. Often times, this subset is often seen as positive, therefore negating any consequence or fault that this myth may have. The model minority myth was created in 1966 by sociologist William Petersen in an article, â€Å"Success Story: Japanese AmericanRead MoreThe Manufactured Crisis Essay1510 Words   |  7 Pagesschool systems are failing and that in order to make their children successful they have to be sent to private schools. The Manufactured Crisis is a well written book jammed packed full of research and observation that overwhelming disproves the myths and bashing of public school systems. In chapter one Biddle and Berliner grab you attention right away this throwing a number of news headings at you. Most of these headings read something like, â€Å"Fourteen-year-old student, repeatedly tormented andRead MoreAn Analysis Of The Model Minority Stereotype1676 Words   |  7 PagesScience, Society 20 November 2014 An Analysis of the Model Minority Stereotype INTRODUCTION According to the 2010 United States Census, those that identify as Asian numbered more than 14 million people, approximately 4.8% of the entire United States population (SOURCE). Despite or perhaps due to being a relatively small population, Asian Americans are not exempt from stereotyping. While a stereotype does not technically have positive or negative connotations and is simply a widely held generalizationRead MoreStereotyping of Asian American Youth: The Effects on Performance in Academics846 Words   |  4 Pagesdiscrimination. This paper will be primarily focus on the discrimination towards Asian American youth of the 21st century and how it affects their academics. The research question guiding this investigation is â€Å"To what extent does the stereotyping of Asian American high school students as the model minority impact their performance on standardized tests such as ACT?† The focus will lead towards the stereotyping of Asian American students such as smart, mat h geniuses, or good at everything and how thisRead MoreIs Model Minority A Bane Or Benefit Essay2188 Words   |  9 PagesModel Minority a bane or benefit​ ​ ​Model minority is a myth that prescribes the Asian-descent group as intelligent, diligent and family-oriented. Appraising the community as highly gifted in science and rich in financial base, the Whites appeal other races to learn from them. However, as a saying goes, â€Å"all is not gold that glitters.† The titles of â€Å"doctors† or â€Å"triumphant† are so enticing that may cover up the damages beneath it. The myth is indeed more of a bane than a benefit, especially whenRead MoreRape, Sexual, And Sexual Abuse1506 Words   |  7 Pagesdifferences are a factor for rape as well. For example, Asian American women assaults may be underreported because they feel like it brings shame to the victims and their families to disclose such information to law enforcement. There are certain myths about rape. Reviews of literature revealed which is not a surprise that men are more incline to believe these myths about rape. One of the myths that women act or dress inappropriately. This myth can also vary by ethnicity within women, European AmericansRead MoreRacial Formation : Racism And Race983 Words   |  4 Pagesarbitrary and non-consistent means. Americans tend to infer a lot about other people based on their appearance. When we cannot pin down what someone is it makes us uncomfortable since we can categorize them. We use media to perpetuate stereotypes and myths which later become immutable so called truths. We have a tendency to racialize people in order to better control people. In this sense, we have formed race in a way that is unstable. Cornell, Hartmann – Ethnicity and Race Ethnicity and Race are veryRead MoreWomen s Death And The King s Horseman And M. Butterfly1393 Words   |  6 Pageson women of the orient misrepresented his judgment resulting to him being fooled by the opera singer on his true sexual identity. The sexist perception of Gallimard towards Asian women made him fall in love with a man whom he thought of as a woman. The playwright has reasonably thought of portraying the stereotype used on Asian woman by using a man in place of the woman. It has at least added humor and revenge on the part of the women to see a stereotyping and insensitive man suffer the consequences